Pure Benchmarks Logo

Pure Benchmarks · Guide

How to Make Investment Decisions Without Letting Emotion Take Over

Short answer

You cannot remove emotion from investing, but you can move the important decisions to a time when emotion is low. Write rules in advance for what would justify buying, selling and rebalancing. Add a waiting period between wanting to act and acting. Use a short checklist that forces a reason, a size and an exit onto paper. And measure your own past decisions against doing nothing, because objective evidence about how you behave under pressure is more persuasive than any rule. A 2021 Journal of Finance study found that investors given objective peer comparison data panic-sold less in downturns.

Almost every investing mistake people regret was made in a moment of strong feeling: fear during a crash, excitement during a rally, envy when a friend made money. The advice to stay calm is true and useless, because the moment you most need it is the moment you can least follow it. This page is about practical structure instead: ways of making the decision before the emotion arrives, slowing it down when it does, and using evidence about your own behaviour to keep yourself honest.

Decide the rules before you need them

Write down, while markets are calm, what would justify selling a holding, what would justify buying more, how often you rebalance and by how much a holding can drift before you act. Rules made in advance are decisions made by the calm version of you. When the market is falling, the job becomes following the rule rather than inventing one under pressure.

Add a cooling-off period

Set a fixed wait, such as 48 hours or a week, between deciding to make an unplanned change and making it. Most urgent-feeling decisions look different after a few days. If the reason still holds after the wait, the delay cost very little. If it does not, the wait prevented a decision driven by the moment.

Use a short checklist

Before any trade outside your rules, answer on paper: Why am I doing this? What do I know now that I did not know before? How much, and what would make me reverse it? What would I do with the money otherwise? Am I reacting to news, a price move or someone else’s result? A checklist does not stop a bad decision, but it makes one harder to make without noticing.

Watch less often

Checking a portfolio several times a day exposes you to more small losses, which feel worse than equal gains feel good. Many people make better decisions simply by looking weekly or monthly. Nothing about a long-term plan requires minute-by-minute information.

Let evidence about yourself do the persuading

Rules are easier to follow when you have seen what breaking them cost. Your transaction history shows what you did in past selloffs and rallies, and pricing those decisions against the do-nothing portfolio turns them into numbers. A 2021 Journal of Finance study found investors given objective peer comparison data panic-sold less in downturns. Pure Benchmarks, our own product, provides both the do-nothing comparison and the peer ranking from connected holdings.

Your current platform won't show you how your portfolio ranks against real investors in the same risk category. Create your secure Pure Benchmarks account and see exactly where you stand.

See Your Free Benchmark Report

Frequently asked questions

How do I stop making emotional investment decisions?

Write rules for buying, selling and rebalancing while markets are calm, add a waiting period before acting on unplanned changes, use a short written checklist, check the portfolio less often, and look at what your past emotional decisions actually cost against doing nothing.

What are common emotional investing mistakes?

Selling in a panic during a fall, buying after a big rise because of fear of missing out, holding losers to avoid admitting a mistake, selling winners too early to lock in a gain, and trading more after a run of success. Each is well documented in investor-behaviour research.

Does checking my portfolio less often help?

For many people it does. Frequent checking exposes you to more short-term losses, which tend to feel worse than equivalent gains feel good, and can prompt changes a long-term plan does not need.

Should I use rules or judgment for investing?

Rules for the decisions most affected by emotion, such as selling in a fall or rebalancing, and judgment for writing and occasionally revising those rules while calm. The point is to separate when you decide from when you feel strongly.

How can I see how emotion has affected my returns?

Compare your actual portfolio with the version in which you made no changes, particularly around past selloffs and rallies. Pure Benchmarks, our own product, does this from connected holdings and ranks the result against verified investors in the same risk category.

Keep exploring

See how a specific firm's advisor decisions compare to other firms:

New here? Read the portfolio benchmarking FAQ or the Pure Benchmarks blog.

This page is an information baseline for comparison only. It is not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy, sell, replace, or transfer any specific asset, account, or firm. Past performance does not guarantee future results. All figures shown are illustrative.